Chess across the world.

DrDave's picture

I had a nice chat at the Spring tournament with Mr Pasupalety and Mr Sequiera, both of whom grew up playing chaturanga. This is thought to be the ancestor of many types of chess played now across the world.

Chaturanga is a slow game, where the pawns can move only one square, there is no such thing as castling, and the Queen, called a Minister, is the weakest piece on the board!  The Bishops (Camels, or in some places Elephants) also had a different move.  When chess first came to Europe, it was in a form quite like this, and medieval chess had this same slow style.

When Western chess-players started experimenting in the opening in the 1920s, they invented some defences where Black stayed away from the centre for a while, and these set-ups look like the set-ups used in chaturanga.  And that's where we get the names King's Indian Defence, Queen's Indian Defence, and so on.

Queen's Indian Defence King's Indian Defence
rnbqkb-r
p-pp-ppp
-p--pn--

rnbqkb-r
ppp-pp-p
---p-np-

When I first looked at the history of Western Chess, I thought that the original game was Chaturanga, a game played in India before 600AD. Chess as played in other countries seems to come from the Arab form of Chess called Shatranj. And that is what I used to tell people.

Chaturanga > Shatranj >     Chinese Chess (Xiang-Chi)
      >     Japanese Chess (Shogi)
      > Medieval chess > Modern Western chess

But I now believe that the best picture that fits what we know says that Chaturanga and Shatranj were both later forms of an original game, which we don't know much about.  And whether China and Japan learned about chess from India or the Arab world, I don't know.

Sort-of-chess > Chaturanga >     Chinese Chess (Xiang-Chi)
  > Shatranj >     Japanese Chess (Shogi)
      > Medieval chess > Modern Western chess

We know lots about shatranj, because there is a lot of writing about it.  Although the players were playing a different game, we can tell from their analysis that they were as good at shatranj as grandmasters are at chess.  In fact, al-Suli composed a chess problem that took hundreds of years for anyone to solve!

I had thought of shatranj and chaturanga as part of chess history, so I was very excited to meet people who had grown up with chaturanga as a living game.

There are lots of different sorts of chess around the world that seem to come from the same stock, including:

  • Shatar (Mongolian Chess)
  • Sittuyin (Burmese Chess)
  • Makruk (Thai Chess)

Each form of chess seems to have its own special rule that makes the game come alive. Burmese chess is the only sort of chess where you can decide where to put your pieces at the start of the game; Japanese chess is the only sort of chess that uses the 'drops' that we see in Exchange Chess; Chinese Chess is the only sort of chess that has the Cannon piece; modern Western Chess is the only sort of chess that has the super-duper Queen. (In fact, our game used to be called Le Jeu de la Dame enragée -- the game with the Mad Queen!).  Castling, and the double-first-move of the pawn, are also later inventions in the Western tradition.

You can read about all these different sorts of chess here:
http://chessvariants.org/
http://www.ancientchess.com/page/free-downloads.htm