Reflections 2023

I haven’t played serious chess for a while and doubt I will again.  The chess achievement I am proudest of is winning the Exeter Chess Club Championship six times.  However, I think I have never been the best player in the club, certainly not the highest-rated, on any of these occasions.  So how come?  In a Swiss, you have to win all or most of your games, and there’s usually one crucial game against the favourite.  Evaluations and ?! mostly by Stockfish and me.

2003-2004: graham bolt – The briar patch

This was before Graham’s Hedghog period, and he rather helpfully played into a line that I knew fairly well and which I think is not dangerous to Black.  Graham of course is highly dangerous, but seemed content to wait for me to lose rather than press strongly for his own cause.

2004-2005: Brian Hewson – the patriarch

Brian is a very experienced and practical player but allowed himself to covet a pawn, which gave me a sustained initiative that was wearisome to defend against, resulting in a slip.

2006-2007: Simon Waters – the centre

Simon is a big old-fashioned centre-forward of a player, who has got the better of me more than once in complications.  Lots of elementary errors after his pawn sac.

2012-2013: Pablo Medina – the briar patch 2

Pablo’s forthright style made a big impression on us all but chose in this last-round play-off game to avoid any possible preparation by discarding his favourite 1.e4 for 1.d4 and a Dutch.  I had to be more familiar with this than Pablo but I didn’t especially outplay him, he just lost his way late in the game.

2013-2014: Tim Paulden – the briar patch 3

In a rather loud echo of the last game, Tim sought to avoid any of my prep by… playing into my main defensive system, so I always felt comfortable and got on top.

2014-2015: Tim Paulden – A waltz on the clifftop

We both prepped for this — Tim’s favourite at the time was the Nimzo-Larsen, which I believed then and now can be handled with a sensible move order, but I very quickly grabbed a hot pawn and soon regretted it.  Yet I found a little wrinkle at the end of a forcing line and Tim followed me down the garden path.

2014-2015: LAURENTZ Hartmann – a tale of two bishops

Laurentz and I both played this Botvinnik system, and on the day he thoroughly outplayed me in the opening and got an equal game at least.  I kept a straight face and kept going, and gradually took over the light squares.

 

Book recommendations

I was recently asked for some book recommendations, and thought easy-peasy, I’ll  point them to something online.  Then I looked at some lists, and thought I’d write my own…  Just books, not videos or Chessable courses.  Lots of really great books
omitted.  The ChessDojo list isn’t too bad.

Openings Tactics Strategy Endgames Praxis Bonus
Beginner HERTAN. Basic Chess Openings for Kids GILLAM Simple Chess Tactics and Checkmates CHERNEV The Most Instructive Games of Chess
Ever Played(*)
KOSTEN Winning Endgames del GIOCONDO A first book of Morphy WEBB Chess for Tigers
D EMMS Discovering Chess Openings CHERNEV/REINFELD Winning Chess(*) STEAM Simple Chess(*)
EMMS Simple Chess
CHERNEV Capablanca’s 60 Best Chess Endgames HARTSTON Kings of Chess
RETI Masters of the Chessboard(*)
C One-volume basic opening repertoire e.g.
COLLINS Simple Chess Repertoire
MacDONALD Starting Out: French
AAGAARD/LUND Meeting 1.d4 (Tarrasch Defence)
SEIRAWAN Winning Chess Tactics
VUKOVIC The Art of Attack
EMMS More Simple Chess
SEIRAWAN/SILMAN Winning Chess Strategy
SEIRAWAN Winning Chess Endgames FISCHER My 60 Memorable Games TAL Life and Games
B Picking a style e.g.
EMMS Attacking with 1.e4
WATSON A Strategic Opening Repertoire for White
GALLAGHER Play the King’s Indian
EMMS Easy Guide to the Nimzo-Indian
WATSON Play the French
GOLUBEV Easy Guide to the Dragon
BURGESS Instructive Chess Puzzles SILMAN Reassess Your Chess
HANSEN Improve your Positional Chess
SILMAN Complete Endgame Course (first few
chapters)
BOTVINNIK My Best Chess Games 1940-67 ROWSON The Seven Deadly Chess Sins
A WATSON Mastering the Chess Openings 1-4 JACOBS Analyse to Win WATSON Chess Strategy in Action van PERLO Endgame Tactics NUNN Secrets of Grandmaster Play ROWSON Chess for Zebras
CM AAGAARD Grandmaster Preparation: Calculation AAGAARD Grandmaster Preparation: Positional
play
AAGAARD Grandmaster Preparation: Endgames STOHL Modern Chess Masterpieces KASPAROV My Great Predecessors 1-5

(*) Originally in Descriptive but Algebraic available

Juniors: start with my books with Tim Onions, then graduate to the Gambit books ‘for  Kids’, apart from their Opening one, which is a boring catalogue.

P.S. Compilers of chess book lists: do split your list by level, and don’t recommend books available only in Descriptive, or My System.  I know, My System is a great book, but there are better books to learn that stuff from now.  When I was a boy, it was literally in a class by itself, but not now.  See also: Bobby Fischer Teaches Chess, Chess Fundamentals, Ideas behind the chess openings etc etc

Why chess books don’t work

Nate Solon has just provoked with a blog on Lichess:
Why Chess Books Don’t Work

He has some point — I mean, if books made you a better chess player, I should be world champion by now…

But I commented, crossly:

To the extent that Chessable has a theory of learning, it’s a very impoverished one.

I believe Pillsbury was once challenged to remember a list of obscure words, starting Antiphlogistine, Madjesoomalops etc
Spaced repetition/recall seems perfect for this task where any meaning in the content is irrelevant.

A book will have, as you suggest, an implicit theory of learning, but I suspect will be richer than you give it credit for, perhaps having several on one page. I don’t know if you know the book Winning Chess by Chernev and Reinfeld — I suspect both authors would struggle to articulate a ‘theory of learning’ of the sort you seem to think is required, but what a great pair of teachers.

I know many books from Everyman which use the Socratic method, of presenting a question before giving an explanation.
Others engage with wit, colourful language, striking examples, slogans, scaffolded exercises etc. Implicit maybe but Ford save us all from learning opening lines by rote.

Good-quality verbal explanations in books can unlock a whole opening system for you, as can a good example.

The right book at the right time can produce a step-wise improvement — I can remember two or three from my early playing days (Winning Chess Chernev/Reinfeld, Middle Game I & II Euwe/Kramer, Secrets of Practical Chess Nunn).

Perhaps the reason most books don’t ‘work’ is because most books are not good books — or not good for you at the time.

I can remember acquiring, on Silman’s recommendation, the book on Combinations by Znosko-Borovsky. I learned nothing from it, as Chernev/Reinfeld had done their job well. I also learned next to nothing from Fine’s Basic Chess Endings — it was far too advanced for me when I picked it up.